If modal verbs feel like a jumble you cannot sort out, don’t worry — we will put them in order. In this article, you will see when to use can, must, should, may and might, how they differ in practice, and how not to mix up a polite request with a prohibition. If you want the bigger picture first, you may also like our post about how many English modal verbs there are, and for a comparison of meanings, see the article about when to use should.
In short: modal verbs help you talk about ability, necessity, advice, permission and probability. They do not change like ordinary verbs, they do not need do in questions and negatives, and they like to be followed by the base form of a verb without to. They are a bit like grammar VIPs: they go in first, skip the queue, and make the other verbs behave properly.
1. Can — be able to, be allowed to, have the possibility
Can is used when we talk about ability, possibility, or permission in everyday neutral English. It is the most common of the five and usually the first one students learn.
For example:
- I can swim. — I know how to swim.
- Can you help me? — Can you help me?
- You can take a seat. — You are welcome to sit down.
In questions asking for permission, can sounds natural in everyday speech. In a very formal style, however, you will more often see may. Cambridge says that can is standard in speech, while may appears more often in very formal instructions.
It is also worth remembering one simple rule: can does not combine with another modal verb. So we do not say can must or can might. In such cases, you need a different structure.
If you want to go deeper, a good follow-up is the post about how to use to be able to, because that is the structure that helps us in tenses where can alone does not work.
2. Must — obligation or a strong conclusion
Must is strong, direct, and sometimes sounds like a teacher who already knows who did not do the homework. We use it to express obligation or a very strong belief.
For example:
- You must wear a helmet. — You have to wear a helmet.
- I must go now. — I have to go now.
- She must be tired. — She is definitely tired.
Cambridge English Grammar Today distinguishes must as obligation and as deduction; in the second case, we are making a conclusion based on evidence.
One important catch: in English, must is not exactly the same as the Polish verb meaning “have to.” In many situations, have to is a better fit, especially when the pressure comes from outside, such as rules or circumstances. That is why we often say I have to leave rather than using “must” in every case. If you want to explore this pair further, see the post about how to tell should apart from a stronger tone and the one about how modals work in deduction.
In negatives, mustn’t means prohibition: You mustn’t smoke here. — You are not allowed to smoke here. By contrast, can’t more often means “it is impossible” than “it is not allowed.” It is a tiny word, but it can cause a lot of confusion.

3. Should — advice, sensible suggestion, expectation
Should is a softer “ought to.” It does not sound like grammar police. It sounds more like a sensible friend saying, “Honestly, that would be a good idea.”
- You should study more. — It would be wise for you to study more.
- They should be here soon. — They ought to be here soon.
- You shouldn’t eat that much sugar. — You ought not to eat that much sugar.
This modal is also very common for expectations and predictions: An hour should be enough. — One hour ought to be enough. Cambridge says that should is often used for expectations, probability and predictions.
If you want to compare it with other structures, see our post about when to use should, because there we also explain should have done, the classic “you should have done it.”
4. May — possibility and formal permission
May is a little more elegant than can. We usually use it to talk about possibility and to ask for permission politely.
- It may rain later. — It might rain later.
- She may be at work. — She might be at work.
- May I ask a question? — May I ask a question?
Cambridge lists may as a modal verb expressing possibility and permission.
In practice, may can sound more formal and polite than can. So:
- Can I leave now? — sounds natural and informal,
- May I leave now? — sounds more official.
If you want to understand better why may and might are so often confused, a separate post on how the pair may and might works will help.
5. Might — weaker possibility, “maybe, but I would not bet on it”
Might usually shows a lower probability than may. In everyday use the difference can be small, but if you want to sound precise, it is worth knowing.
- She might come. — Perhaps she will come.
- It might be a mistake. — It might be a mistake.
- We might go to Kraków next week. — Perhaps we will go to Kraków next week.
Cambridge describes might as a modal expressing weak possibility. It also notes its use in polite suggestions.
That is why might is great when we do not want to sound too certain. It is the language equivalent of a shrug: “maybe yes, maybe no, we will see.”
The key differences in one place
So you do not get lost in the modal jungle, remember it like this:
- can — ability, possibility, informal permission,
- must — obligation or a strong conclusion,
- should — advice, duty, expectation,
- may — possibility and formal permission,
- might — weaker possibility, a less certain “maybe.”
A good way to learn is not to study these words separately, but in pairs and contrasts. For example:
- Can I borrow your pen? — a normal, everyday question.
- May I borrow your pen? — more formal.
- You should rest. — good advice.
- You must rest. — strong obligation or recommendation.
- He may be late. — possible.
- He might be late. — even less certain.
Quick negative forms cheat sheet
In negatives, modal verbs also behave in their own way:
- can’t — cannot / impossible,
- mustn’t — must not / not allowed,
- shouldn’t — ought not to,
- may not — may not / perhaps not,
- might not — may not, but with less certainty.
This matters because in English one negative does not always mean the same as another. For example, You mustn’t go and You don’t have to go are completely different messages. The first means “you are not allowed to,” the second means “you do not need to.” English is full of little traps like that.
Exercise: insert can, must, should, may or might
Try to complete the sentences with one of the five modal verbs:
- You ______ study more if you want to pass.
- He ______ be at home, but I’m not sure.
- ______ I open the window?
- You ______ drive after drinking.
- I ______ speak English, but I’m still learning.
Answers:
- should
- might
- May
- mustn’t
- can
If you want, try a harder version too: turn each sentence into a negative or a question. That really helps, because modal verbs are best learned in use, not from a dry table.
English joke: when your nose does the running for you
You should run every morning. — You ought to run every morning.
My nose runs every morning. Does that count? — My nose runs (drips) every morning. Does that count?
Should gives advice here. The coach uses run in the sense of “jog,” and the other person answers with my nose runs, meaning “I have a runny nose.” The coach suggested exercise, and the speaker counted a cold as training.
Finally: practice modal verbs in conversation
If you really want to master can, must, should, may and might, reading alone is not enough. The best method is to speak in full sentences, listen to questions, and answer aloud. That is how you learn comprehension, recall vocabulary, and speak naturally at your own pace, without stress and without guessing which modal to choose.
If you want to practise in a practical way, create an account in the form below and try SPEAKINGO in conversation, not just in theory.